This ruling is based on the written submissions of Mr Jackson Mthembu, for the ANC, and the Mail & Guardian newspaper.
The ANC complains about a story in the Mail & Guardian on 15 June 2012 and headlined ‘Prove you’re not a dictator’: NEC in heated Zuma attack.
The ANC complains that the following statements in the story are untrue, namely that:
The ANC also complains that the newspaper based its reportage on a malicious SMS and ignored its official account of the meeting.
The story starts as follows: “Zuma’s backers and foes in the ANC’s top brass have nailed their colours to the mast in a fiery (NEC) meeting in which he was accused of suppressing debate.” It also says that senior leader General Siphiwe Nyanda, who led the “assault” on Zuma, challenged him to prove that he was not a dictator. The review application by the ANC Youth League and its expelled president, Mr Julius Malema, reportedly exposed sharp divisions in the ANC’s top leadership.
In its reply to the complaint the M&G says that it scarcely used the SMS, but largely based the story on information from four independent sources (from inside the NEC) who attended the meeting. It also points me to “supportive reports” in both the Sunday Times and City Press.
Untrue statements
The story ascribes all the statements that the ANC complains about to sources. These sources had the right to say what they did, and the newspaper had the right to publish them. The issue, therefore, is about the credibility of these sources.
I asked the editor of the M&G if he could reveal their names to me, but he was in no position to do so – a decision that I respect.
Ignoring the ANC’s official account
The ANC complains that the newspaper based its reportage on a malicious SMS and ignored its official account of the meeting.
Please note that our Complaints Procedures lay down that within seven days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Ralph Zulman, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at Khanyim@ombudsman.org.za.